Debate over wearing masks in schools rises as academic year begins for some
It's still July, but the 2021-22 school year has started for some students around the country, even as coronavirus cases are rising sharply in places with low vaccination rates and contentious debates about mask mandates are escalating.
Despite strong hopes that the new school year would mark a return to full-time, in-school learning normalcy after more than a year of unprecedented pandemic disruptions, school district leaders are facing new challenges to achieving that goal.
With the now-dominant delta variant of the virus far more contagious than earlier ones, coronavirus cases are sharply rising among Americans who have not been vaccinated. Nearly half of the country has been fully vaccinated, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Health officials say there is no evidence that the delta variant affects children and adolescents differently than earlier ones - and the vast majority of the 4 million young people who were infected since the pandemic began did not become severely ill, with many showing no symptoms. They health officials say, though, that because the delta variant is more contagious, more children could get it and carry it home to people who aren't vaccinated. Vaccinated people can also get what is known as "breakthrough" infections, though hospitalizations and deaths are nearly all among the unvaccinated.
As complications with the delta variant continue to emerge, school district officials looking for masking guidance from expert sources are finding differing information.
The CDC has said that vaccinated students and adults do not have to mask in schools but all unvaccinated people should. But President Joe Biden said on July 21 that the CDC would "probably" recommend that all children under 12 - who are not yet eligible for vaccination - all wear masks in school.
But the American Academy of Pediatrics, the nation's leading association of pediatricians, as well as some other health experts, have recommended that everyone over age 2 wear masks indoors, including those who have been vaccinated.
Francis S. Collins, director of the National Institutes of Health, said he trusts the AAP. "They will not be popular amongst parents and kids who are sick of masks, but you know what? The virus doesn't care that we're sick of masks," Collins said Monday in an interview with MSNBC.
Wearing masks has been cited by health experts as one of the most effective health measures to stop the spread of the coronavirus. In late June, a report by two Duke University scientists who reviewed data from March through June 2021 in 100 school districts and 14 charter schools in North Carolina found that wearing masks effectively prevented the transmission of the virus in schools and on buses even without physical distancing.
But those opposed to mask mandates say that local areas should have the choice about what to do in schools depending on local conditions. Many states are not requiring masks be worn in schools - even in the unvaccinated, leaving it to districts to decide.
But some Republican-led states, including Arkansas, which has one of the highest infection rates, has barred schools and government agencies from issuing mask mandates. A group of Democratic legislators in Arkansas has urged the ban to be lifted.
Vaccines are currently available for all Americans age 12 and older, which is why the state of Virginia is strongly urging that everybody in elementary schools - children and adults - wear masks indoors when the 2021-22 school year begins. The new recommendations call for everybody in middle and high school who are not vaccinated to wear masks indoors. The recommendations, however, are not binding, and school districts can make their own rules.
In Democratic-led California, the Department of Public Health on July 12 ordered that all students and staff inside K-12 schools should wear masks - regardless of vaccination status - but announced hours later that it would maintain its masking order but let districts decide how to carry it out and enforce it. Two advocacy groups just sued state officials over the mandate.
While some districts, such as the Los Angeles Unified School District, the second-largest in the country, said it would enforce the mandate, others have said they would not.
Linda Darling-Hammond, president of the California Board of Education, said last week at a Washington Post Live event that masking for everybody in schools is the safest way to proceed for now.
"Not only do we have the delta variant, we have epsilon, all the way up to lamda," she said. "Case rates are doubling ... everybody wants to take their mask off. Until then we should do the safest things we can in schools for kids," she said.
In the Chula Vista Elementary School District in Southern California, the 2021-22 school year began on July 21 with a full-day, in-person schedule. At Enrique S. Camarena Elementary School, Principal Debra McLaren told Fox 5 that all but about 50 of approximately 1,000 students signed up for in-person learning. At the festive opening, McLaren danced to Bobby McFerrin's "Don't Worry, Be Happy" and said, "It's exhilarating," Fox 5 reported.
In Florida, Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis has made clear strong opposition to mask mandates in schools - despite a rising number of coronavirus cases in the state and demands by some parents that masks be worn.
"There's been talk about potentially people advocating at the federal level, imposing compulsory masks on kids," DeSantis said. "We're not doing that in Florida, OK? We need our kids to breathe."
In Orange County, some teachers parents are demanding that masks be required, according to WFTV, though the school board so far has made no move to mandate them.
"They must revisit this before preplanning, before teachers have to return to school," WFTV quoted Orange County Teachers Association President Wendy Doromal as saying. "And certainly before students have to return to school. It's very reckless to make decisions and not look at them again."
In New York City, the nation's largest public school district, all students and adults will be required to wear masks when the new school year starts. Democratic Mayor Bill de Blasio said at a news conference that the mandate could change but that "we'll be driven by the data we see and the science as always."
In neighboring New Jersey, Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy said he would drop the state masking requirement and allow districts to make their own masking rules. And Roy Cooper, the Democratic governor of North Carolina, where some students just started the 2021-22 school year in-person, said something similar: He will not reinstate a mask mandate when it runs out at the end of July but issued recommendations for schools.
Saying "we know masks work," Cooper, along with the state health department, issued recommendations saying that everybody in K-8 grades should wear masks inside a school building while only the unvaccinated should do so in grades 9-12.
In Durham, N.C., schools, where some students have started the new school year, everybody will wear masks for now. "I'm not going to predict any action by our board but we know that masks work and masks make a lot of people more comfortable," ABC11 quoted Chip Sudderth, Durham Public Schools' chief communications officer, as saying. "And so that's how we're going to start the school year."
With COVID-19 hospitalizations rising in Louisiana, Democratic Gov. John Bel Edwards and the Louisiana Department of Health just issued updated guidance saying that all people - whatever their vaccination status - should wear masks indoors when they can't distance at least 6 feet. The guidance, however, isn't binding.
Kavita Patel, a physician who is a nonresident fellow at the nonprofit Brookings Institution and a former policy official in the Obama administration, said recently on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" that having everybody wearing masks made more sense than trusting people who are not vaccinated to always wear one.
"What we are seeing right now is that people aren't doing it," she said. "We are kind of trusting everyone, and I don't see a reason to do that."
Peter Jay Hotez, founding dean of the Baylor University College of Medicine and an expert on vaccines said recently on MSNBC's "Stephanie Ruhle Reports" that universal mask mandates should be imposed rather than having school officials spend time determining who has been vaccinated and who hasn't.
Stories that may interest you
FBI agents and police swarmed the home of a young man wanted for questioning in the disappearance of his girlfriend, Gabby Petito
Pfizer says its COVID-19 vaccine works for children ages 5 to 11
The United States' known death toll from COVID-19 will surpass the number of dead from the Spanish Flu within the next day or two, according to the side-by-side numbers — though a direct comparison between the raw numbers doesn’t give the whole story, medical experts and statisticians...
Anthony S. Fauci, the White House's chief coronavirus medical adviser, said data about booster shots for those who had received the Moderna or Johnson & Johnson coronavirus vaccines could be a few weeks away from being reviewed by the Food and Drug Administration, days after an FDA panel...